Bookinfluencers.com Blog
  • For Authors/Brands
  • For Book influencers
  • Testimonials
  • Book Tours
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Details

Home > Popular > How Using a Reading Tracker Changed My Reading Habits

How Using a Reading Tracker Changed My Reading Habits

Jenny November 20, 2026
Share

I used to think that the only way to track books was to use an “official” method, such as Goodreads. Then I started my Bookstagram in 2019 and used that as a place to track my reading. However, neither really worked for me. I don’t always want to rate with stars, I want to see  patterns in my reading, and I couldn’t always do that with Goodreads and Instagram.

So, I started a reading tracker. Now, I have tried multiple methods across the years and I will share the pros and cons of the ones I’ve tried, and what I currently do. One thing that has remained consistent is my enjoyment of having a place to track my own personal reading goals. I find the ritual of completing my trackers after finishing a book helps me cement my thoughts and feelings on the title.

If you’ve thought about moving on from Goodreads, and want to consider other ways to track your reading, read on!

In Short: How a Reading Tracker Helps Switching from public platforms like Goodreads to a personal reading tracker (such as a spreadsheet, paper journal, or StoryGraph) removes the pressure of public star ratings. It helps prevent “book amnesia”, uncovers hidden genre biases, removes guilt around DNFing (Did Not Finish) books, and turns finishing a story into a mindful ritual.

What Are the Best Reading Tracker Methods to Use? 

I’ve used so many types of reading tracker, and currently, I have 3 that I love. I know, that is overkill, but they all scratch different parts of my brain.

  • Digital Spreadsheets (Best for data and objective ratings): I use a book tracking spreadsheet for two main reasons: firstly, to help me decide on a fair rating. I use the CAWPILE spreadsheet created by G from BookRoast, which is a weighted rating method that scores seven elements out of ten (character, atmosphere, writing style, plot, intrigue, logic, and enjoyment) to calculate an overall star rating. For me, this helps me consider what I genuinely liked about a book rather than rating purely based on vibes. I also love a digital sheet for the charts and data it easily generates.
  • Physical Reading Journals (Best for creativity and screen-free reflection): This is where I write reviews and decorate each page to suit the book’s aesthetic. If you are looking for creative reading journal ideas, using a blank notebook gives you complete freedom. My journal is my space to unwind and enjoy some screen-free time.
  • The StoryGraph (Best Goodreads alternative for infographics): If you are looking for a Goodreads alternative, this is (in my opinion) the best of both worlds. I can write reviews, use quarter-star ratings, and track a lot of information in pretty infographics.
A reading journal spread

How Does a Reading Tracker Change Your Reading Habits? 

It Cured My “Book Amnesia”

We’ve all been there. We finish a book and really enjoy it, but a couple of months later when asked why, we come up blank. “I, um, I liked the main character…and there was a dog? Or was it a cat?” For me, this “book amnesia” was greatly reduced when I started using trackers. I didn’t magically remember every characters name, but spending 5 minutes really thinking about what I specifically enjoy about a book, or which micro tropes it includes helps to cement the story in my mind. I also love pulling quotes that mean something, and decorating a review page to give me the aesthetic of the book. Plus, there is something so pleasing by flicking through my journal from last year to see what I specifically loved about a book, or comparing data in my spreadsheet from previous years.

I Stopped Reading for an Algorithm

Now look, I love Storygraph. I think it is an amazing reading tracker app. However, there is a certain amount of public performance when you share your reads on an app. Will you be judged for rating that popular book 2 stars? What if you want to keep track of something that Storygraph doesn’t? Do you bypass your goals to fit what the app wants?

A private tracker removes the audience. You can use your own rating scale. Why do we use 5 stars anyway? Why not 10? You can rate on a chilli pepper scale for romance, or stabby knives for thrillers, or dragons for fantasy. Saying this book was 8 dragons might not make sense to anyone else, but why should it? 

You can also celebrate niche obsessions and track what matters to you. This year, I wanted to read more diversely. I can’t easily track that on an app, but I can in my own private spreadsheet. I also like to track micro-tropes in romance books so that I can start to drill down into what I adore about specific books. No app gives me a section for including ‘who did this to you’ or the ‘taking care of you’ trope.

 It Exposed My Reading Blind Spots

This is a big one for me. I always thought that I read widely. Yes, perhaps my most read genre is fantasy, but surely it’s only just over a third of all books? Colour me surprised when I saw that over half of the books I logged this year were fantasy. While tracking apps will log genres, they often use crowd-sourced tags that include five or six sub-genres, which waters down your actual results. 

I also love to look back at a year’s worth of data.My “worst” reading months for the last three years have consistently been over the summer, from June to August. Now that I know this pattern, I don’t pressure myself to read more during the summer  I also know that if I read well over my average one month, the next month I tend to go into a slump and see an increase in DNFs (Did Not Finish). This tells me to slow down. I don’t need to read 15+ books a month! 

Something that I want to track next year is specific reasons for DNFing books, so hopefully I can learn what I don’t enjoy so I can read more books I do enjoy!

A digital tracker

 It Killed My “DNF Guilt”

Speaking of DNFs, I’m sure I’m not the only one who sets an annual reading goal on Storygraph or Goodreads, and then power through books at the end of the year because DNFs don’t count and I NEED to hit that goal!

Honestly, I’m pro DNF. I firmly believe that not all books are for everyone, and what I don’t like, someone else will love. But when there is a public goal and I’m 2 books away from hitting it on the 29th December, I probably will power through rather than DNF. 

This is something that I love about my trackers. My digital tracker keeps record of DNFs. They don’t count to my annual count, but I can see how many there are, and the trends around when and why I DNF books. 

Closing a Book Became a Quiet Ritual

Whether you read physically, digitally or via audiobooks, I think a lot of us are guilty of finishing a book, and immediately starting another. My e-reader pops up with a handy list of books I’d like to start next, my TBR (To Be Read) shelf is overflowing and there’s always another book waiting.

However, I now can’t start my next book until I update my trackers. I’ll use my digital spreadsheet to decide on a rating while the plot is fresh in my mind, and then I’ll write my review and decorate my physical journal while I’m still thinking about the characters.

Whether you’re colouring in Book Tetris, writing a review longhand, or typing data into a spreadsheet, tracking your reads allows you to take a deliberate pause and honour a story before moving on.

How to Start a Reading Tracker Without Overthinking It

If you want to start your own reading tracker, go for it! Here are my top tips for getting started without feeling overwhelmed:

  1. Pick one format: paper or screen. If you’re creative and love tactile hobbies, I’d suggest a paper notebook. If you’re more analytical and prefer graphs and data, go for a Google Sheet, Excel spreadsheet, or Notion template.
  2. Start with the basics. Let’s be honest: you’re not going to fill out eight pages or 30 columns of data for every book right away. Start with the title, author, finish date, and a one-line takeaway. If that feels manageable, you can add genre, rating, format, or mood later.
  3. Make life easy for yourself. Keep a pen clipped to your journal, or pin your spreadsheet to your phone’s home screen. Make logging a book a frictionless task rather than something difficult that becomes a chore.
  4. Embrace messy data. Allow yourself to miss titles and catch up later if you need to. I regularly jot down a couple of lines in my journal mid-week and save the creative doodling for a Sunday morning when I want a slow start to the day.

Start Messy, Keep It Yours

At the end of the day, the books you read are personal to you. Even an imperfect list of titles and scattered thoughts can turn into a brilliant time capsule of who you were at that point in your life.

Let me know your preferred tracking method in the comments below, and share if there are any surprising patterns you’ve noticed about your own reading habits!

Recommended Posts

  • 7 South Pacific Books Written by Local and Indigenous Authors

    Jenny November 6, 2026
  • Why We Should Read Diverse Stories All Year Round

    Monisha October 9, 2026
  • Read Around the World: 5 Books from Vietnam You Should Read

    Paula October 2, 2026
  • 5 Cosy Autumn Trends for Book Influencers to Level Up Your Social Media

    Jenny September 25, 2026
  • The Ultimate Guide to LitRPG Books: What They Are & Best Reads

    Paula September 18, 2026

Recent Posts

Self-Service, Full-Service, or UGC: Choosing the Best Book Tour Service for Your Book
Self-Service, Full-Service, or UGC: Choosing the Best Book Tour Service for Your Book
How Using a Reading Tracker Changed My Reading Habits
How Using a Reading Tracker Changed My Reading Habits
AI use at Bookinfluencers.com. Our policy and expectations.
AI use at Bookinfluencers.com. Our policy and expectations.
7 South Pacific Books Written by Local and Indigenous Authors
7 South Pacific Books Written by Local and Indigenous Authors
Spooky Halloween Traditions From Around the World
Spooky Halloween Traditions From Around the World
How to Write Impactful Captions for Instagram
How to Write Impactful Captions for Instagram

authors

Antina (18)
Guest Blogger (19)
Helena Kulikowska (6)
Jenny (39)
Kristin (17)
Maren (19)
Monisha (1)
Paula (29)
Sanne (1)

Categories

Author and Publisher (20) Author Interview (10) Featured (20) Popular (97)
Bookinfluencers.com Blog

Thank you for visiting our blog.
We are the bridge between the reading community and you. Reach out to us if you'd like to collaborate with bookish creators.

Page Links

  • For Authors/Brands
  • For Book influencers
  • Testimonials
  • Book Tours
  • Contact Us

Instagram Feed

bookinfluencerscom

🌎 Global Book Promotions
➡️ 1000+ campaigns, 10K+ creators
📚 For (indie) authors, publishers and bookish brands

SPICY ROMANCE REC 🖤Obsession, enemies-to-lovers an SPICY ROMANCE REC 🖤Obsession, enemies-to-lovers and all the sports romance vibes? We read Hard Count by Lucas Malone (@lucastmalone)! 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️#sportsromance #mmromance #spicyromance
✨ “When a sacred journey is corrupted by ambition, ✨ “When a sacred journey is corrupted by ambition, a quest for unity becomes a struggle for control…” ✨
We read THE WANDERING STARS by J. D. Rasch (@jodyrasch) with our community, a philosophical epic fantasy novel 🔮👉🏼 Swipe to find out what everyone said about this book@ireadbookstours #thewanderingstars #epicfantasy #fantasybooks #fantasyreader
READ AROUND THE WORLD 💫 Have you read a book from READ AROUND THE WORLD 💫 Have you read a book from one of these countries? If the answer is no, this is your sign to do a Read Around The World-challenge! ❤️ We’ve got a lot of recs from you, hand-picked by us and our community.🔗 Find out all the recs on Bookinfluencers.com/blog#readaroundtheworld #readdiverse #ownvoices
HOLIDAY ROMANCE 💖🎄 Here are 24 books to put on you HOLIDAY ROMANCE 💖🎄 Here are 24 books to put on your list this holiday season! Let us know: have you already read a holiday romance? 👀#holidayromancebooks #holidayromance #christmasromance #indieauthors #newbookreleases
BOOKISH CONTENT IDEAS 💜 Do you need some inspirati BOOKISH CONTENT IDEAS 💜 Do you need some inspiration for new bookish content? We are here for you with content ideas for november! 📖 Save this post for later. 👋🏼#bookishcontent #bookinfluencers #bookishcontentideas #bookstagram #contentideas | bookish content ideas for november
An impactful memoir 🤍 Our community discovered Ris An impactful memoir 🤍 Our community discovered Rise After Silence by Anne Aspler (@dr.anneaspler), a memoir of an ER Doctor and the patients who healed her. A beautiful and moving memoir, like many of you said.🚨TRIGGER WARNINGS: sexual assault, domestic abuse, serial rape, schizophrenia and severe mental illness, homelessness, religious fundamentalism, foster care trauma, PTSD, addiction, childhood violence💙 “It left me feeling so moved and reflective. It’s vulnerable, deeply touching, and such a powerful read about breaking the cycle of silence.” - @minaareads💙 “It reminds me how much of what we inherit is beyond our control, but what we choose to carry forward is not” @savor.your.reads💙 “Ultimately this is quite a difficult read featuring some heavy topics, but Aspler handles everything with such warmth, compassion and even litters the pages with some humour along the way. I was genuinely moved in too many ways that once I finished reading, I had to re-read a second time”  @x_miss_mcrae_x#riseaftersilence #memoir #childhoodtrauma #memoirstoread
FIREFLY WEDDING TOUR 🦋 Satoko Kirigaya has everyth FIREFLY WEDDING TOUR 🦋 Satoko Kirigaya has everything a noblewoman could want, except time. With her life running out, she’s determined to marry well. Meet FIREFLY WEDDING by Oreco Tachibana 👰🏻‍♀️🤍📗 Open for US/CA/UK & Irish manga creators
💰 Incentives available - close your own deal on Bookinfluencers.com#mangareaders #mangacommunity #fireflywedding #vizmanga #mangagirl
4 NEW BOOK TOURS 💜 We’ve got 4 international campa 4 NEW BOOK TOURS 💜 We’ve got 4 international campaigns lined up for you in collab with @thewildrosepress. Which one will you be joining this fall? 💫📕 Beyond Valor by H.G. Hedger (@gammiehedger)
📙 Murder Richly Deserved by Roxanne Dunn (@roxannepebblesdunn)
📗 Evergreen Evermore by Margaret Izard (@mizardauthor)
📘 Dying To Meet The Newcomer by Judith Fournie Helms#arcreaderswanted #romanticsuspense #historicalromantasy #fantasyreaders #cosycrime
YA FANTASY TOUR 🏛️ If you loved The Midnight Libra YA FANTASY TOUR 🏛️ If you loved The Midnight Library, meet The Alternate World by Kathryn Starke (@KathrynStarke)! This YA contemporary fantasy makes you think about the choices you make in your life. 💜What are you going to choose to do? Welcome to The Alternate World. 💫THE BOOK TOUR...
🇺🇸 is open for bookish US creators
💰 comes with incentives for creators - close your own deal on the platform
🔗 is waiting for you to join on bookinfluencers.com@CreativeMindsPublications #TheAlternateWorld #yafantasybooks #yafantasy #youngadultfantasy #fantasybooks
ROMANCE BOOK TOUR 🦋 Are you a fan of rivals-to-lov ROMANCE BOOK TOUR 🦋 Are you a fan of rivals-to-lovers, forced proximity, and a hero who falls first? Then we have the perfect campaign for you! 🥰We’re looking for influencers to read and promote A MATCH FOR THE MARQUESS by Chelsea Bobulski (@chelseabobulski). A charming historical romance filled with witty banter, spirited competition & unexpected partnerships. 🏰THIS BOOK TOUR...
🇺🇸 is open for US creators with a minimum of 2K followers
💰 has incentives for influencers - close your own deal on our platform
🔗 waiting for you to join on Bookinfluencers.com#historicalromance #romancebooks #indieromance #amatchforthemarquess #nospice @havenfiction
This YA contemporary NEEDS to be on your TBR, acco This YA contemporary NEEDS to be on your TBR, according to our community. 🧡 We read the newest book by Renee Watson (@harlemportland) with our lovely community. And oh, how we loved this book! This is Everything New Again. ✨👉🏼 Swipe to find out what our community said about this bookHave you read this one yet? 👀#bookstagram #everythingnewagain #yabookstagram #reneewatson @bloomsburypublishing
She was raised in a cult. Now she tears them apart She was raised in a cult. Now she tears them apart. 🤯 Meet THE SILENT DOCTRINE by M.K. Mercer, a new psychological thriller coming to you on November 24th! Come join the new international book tour with us now and find out more. 🤫THIS BOOK TOUR:
🌍 is open international
💰 comes with incentives for creators - close your own deal on the platform
🔗 is waiting for you to join on bookinfluencers.comABOUT THE BOOK
🌄 South of San Francisco, a mountain retreat offers something the modern world has forgotten how to provide: silence. The Solen Center offers people suffering from anxiety, distraction, and stress a unique path to relief. No phones.
🤫 No talking. Only the body, the breath, and a focus on one’s hands. People arrive burned out and leave utterly transformed.
🔐 But unbeknownst to them, inside the therapeutic practice is a secret that turns visitors into future unwitting operatives, committing acts for some of the world’s most dangerous people, with no memory of having done so.
👁️ A peculiar nineteen-minute gap in three apparently unrelated crimes leads FMC Lena to the Solen Center. What she finds there suggests thousands of untraceable, unsolved crimes. But the only way to prove it is for Lena to join.#psychologicalthrillers #thrillers #bookrecommendations #thesilencedoctrine
NOVEMBER RELEASES BY INDIE AUTHORS 💜🕯️ Here are 12 NOVEMBER RELEASES BY INDIE AUTHORS 💜🕯️ Here are 12 books to put on your list this month!✨ Save this post to find your next read
🍂 Let us know your favorite new release for this month below - especially if its an indie one!#novemberreads #indiereleases #newbookrelease #indieauthors #newbookrelease
HAPPY RELEASE DAY TO THE RUSSIAN RISK BY DAHLIA! 🩷 HAPPY RELEASE DAY TO THE RUSSIAN RISK BY DAHLIA! 🩷 If you love books by Elle Kennedy and Ana Huang, this indie release needs to be on your radar. The Russian Risk by Dahlia (@mnightdahlia) is out now. A college romance where he falls first. Swipe to find out more 👉🩷 Opposites Attract
🩷 Dual POV
🩷 He falls first
🩷 “Bad” Boy with a Soft Side
🩷 Family Trouble (MMC)
🩷 Secret Ticking Clock (MMC)
🌶️ Spice level: 3.5 out of 5Add The Russian Risk to your tbr!#therussianrisk #romancebooks #spicyromance #indieromance
PICTURE BOOK REC 🐻‍❄️ We read The Adventures of Be PICTURE BOOK REC 🐻‍❄️ We read The Adventures of Belle Bear by Kathy Akopov Guillory (@belle_be4r) with our community. A heartwarming picture book about courage, self-confidence, and discovering the bravery to be yourself, no matter where life takes you. ❤️📘 Will you add this one to your list?#theadventuresofbellebear #picturebooks #kidlit #childrensbooks #booksforkids
PICK A DRINK, GET A BOOK REC 🧡 Happy Halloween! We PICK A DRINK, GET A BOOK REC 🧡 Happy Halloween! We’ve lined up 6 drinks for you and you will get a hand-picked book rec with it. Which one did you choose? 🎃#halloweenbooks #spookyreads #halloween #pickadrink
THRILLER REC 🖤👁️ Unreliable narrators, buried secr THRILLER REC 🖤👁️ Unreliable narrators, buried secrets, fractured memories, and twists that kept me guessing. Our community had a great time reading When Mountains Crumble(d) by Claudine Discala (claudinediscala) 🧠Fun fact: the author herself was a private investigator for 20 years, which makes this series even more interesting if you ask us!📙 Will you add this series to your tbr?#whenmountainscrumble #psychologicalthriller #thrillerreaders #murdermysterybooks #murdermystery
HORROR READS 🖤 Here are 13 spooky books to put on HORROR READS 🖤 Here are 13 spooky books to put on your list this fall!❤️ SAVE this post for later
🗣️ Did we forget a great new horror release? Let us know in the comments!#newbookrelease #indieauthor #horrorbookstagram #horrorbooks #horrorauthor
LOVE STORY REC 🤍 We read Singer-Songwriter by Kels LOVE STORY REC 🤍 We read Singer-Songwriter by Kelsey Jayne Marshall (@klsy.jm). A perfect book for readers of Carley Fortune, Annabel Monaghan, and Taylor Jenkins Reid.🦋 Set against the backdrop of a close-knit beach town, the novel explores family, grief, identity, and the courage it takes to start over.💫 Swipe to find out what our community said about this book!#romancebooks #womensfiction #romancereaders #singersongwriterbook #kelseyjaynemarshall
FALL MANGA RELEASES 💫 Do you want to read a new vo FALL MANGA RELEASES 💫 Do you want to read a new volume with us this fall? Meet the new titles coming to you from @vizmedia and join the campaigns! 📙📘 Heroes - Inio Asano
📙 Sakamoto Days: Assassin’s Blues - Yuto Suzuki & Renka Misaki
📕 Albus Changes the World, Vol. 1 - Akihisa Maki & Miki Yatsubo
📗 The Seaside Where Dragon Boys Dwell, Vol. 1 - Asato Shima#mangacommunity #newmangareleases #inioasano #mangagirl
Follow on Instagram

2023 © Bookinfluencers.Com. All Rights Reserved.