Bookinfluencers.com Blog
  • For Authors/Brands
  • For Book influencers
  • Testimonials
  • Book Tours
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Details

Home > Featured > The Art of Ethical Book Reviews: Navigating “Problematic” Books with Honesty and Grace

The Art of Ethical Book Reviews: Navigating “Problematic” Books with Honesty and Grace

a wall of rainbow books with the title 'ethical book review: a guide' overlaid on top
Guest Blogger January 16, 2026
Share

By Ana Vanessa Bettencourt De Almeida

Who I Am as a Reviewer and Creator

I am deeply honored to share my personal approach to the complex world of “problematic” literature and ethical book reviews. My perspective is shaped by a life lived on both sides of the page. Known as Ana in the reviewing community and Vanessa in my creative life, I hold a Master’s in English and Portuguese Literature and a Bachelor’s in Fine Arts.

My career has been a journey of storytelling with a lot of setbacks but also character growth: I have taught literature and English in high schools, worked as a professional illustrator for publishers, and personally authored 16 fantasy and non-fiction titles, all of which I illustrated myself. Because I know the weight of the pen and the brush, I approach every book not just as a consumer, but as a fellow creator. This background helps me to inform my own approach to reviewing books ethically, and with open literary critique. Read on for the ways that I choose to review and tips if you chose to emulate my style.

Problematic Doesn’t Mean Wrong

In today’s discourse, “problematic” is often used as a red flag, but I see it as an invitation. A difficult subject brings different opinions to the surface. Problematic books invite conversation rather than cancellation. Good communication between parties with different ideals is essential. This is why these books make the best book club reads. They help us learn about a theme but also about ourselves.

I strive to be an eclectic, open-minded reader. Personally, I don’t believe in “cancel culture” or the banning of books. I created my platform, Therearenobadbooks, because even the clumsiest project can have a solid story at its core. Sometimes an author is too impatient to finish the “loops” of editing, or they hold beliefs radically different from their readers. As long as we are well-informed, we can turn these readings into opportunities for growth. This is why I appreciate the transparency provided by companies like Bookinfluencers.com.

the first two books in the bridgerton series. there is purple flowers on the left and the full series of books at the top right

The Reviewer’s Responsibility and the “No DNF” Rule

Whether you receive a free copy, monetary compensation, or another benefit, be honest. Remember: payment is not for a “bought” opinion. It is to compensate you for your labor, for the hours spent reading, writing, photographing, and the investment in props, lighting, and editing.

Because I value this investment, I personally find it difficult to DNF (Did Not Finish) a book. I am a compulsive reader, finishing as many books as I can every year (a passion that keeps me sane). I always think: What if I’m missing the best part at the end? Besides, I can only form a solid opinion when I experience the whole project. Even if the lesson is simply learning “not to take that path,” it is never, in my opinion, a waste of time.

My Ethical Book Review Method

Starting From a Five-Star Mindset

When I grab a book, I give it 5 stars immediately. Then, I take points away as I encounter elements that don’t resonate. I personally don’t need trigger warnings, but I deeply respect their necessity for others. I believe that as a reviewer, it is our responsibility to consider what content the next person may struggle with. When a book makes me uncomfortable, I report on that feeling with compassion.

The “Beta Reader” Approach

If a book is unpolished, I ignore technical grammar issues to find the core plot. I provide specific feedback to help the author improve future scenes. E.g. Some chapters are missed opportunities to describe amazing action scenes, instead of getting the aftermath from the character in a less exciting exposition. Show, don’t tell.

When I’m Not the Target Audience

If I realize I am not the target audience, I won’t be destructive. I will focus on the positive aspects and perhaps mention that I skimmed certain parts, or that I took notes of the advice provided by the author while still informing my viewers that those elements exist. E.g. even if I’m not a fan of open-door romance descriptions I mention where readers can find these scenes.

The Shift to Digital Reading

If a book is a struggle, and I signed up to write a review, I switch to an eBook format to hide the page count (less overwhelming) or pair an audiobook with the text version to maintain focus.

a woman with a kindle in front of her face

The “Waiting Room” Books

Some books stay on my shelf for ten years before the “right moment” hits. If I truly can’t finish after three attempts, I won’t review it harshly. I provide some positive aspects that may interest the right readers and some reasons that don’t resonate with me. I’ll end up dropping it in a Little Free Library for someone it might actually speak to. If I decided that I don’t want to provide any review, then I’ll reach out to the tour manager or author to explain my reasons and turn the post into a spotlight or book mail video, informing my viewers of the triggers and what to expect, positive and negative.

A Worst-Case Scenario Review Example

Sometimes, there will be a book that just does not resonate, and you have no other option than to give it a constructive, but critical review. Below is a case study example of what I would say in this scenario. This review is entirely fictional.

This project has potential. The secondary character is one of my favorites, but the plotline needs some work after the second part. I hope the author can revisit it. If you like small town stories, this one has a unique crime mystery that is solved without many plot twists. The author has some beliefs that don’t align with my social or political views.

The Artist’s Boundary: AI, Transparency, and Ethics

As a professional artist, I appreciate honesty regarding AI artwork in books. If an author is transparent about using AI, I will state that my review reflects the text alone. I usually start the review with this information. While I personally stay away from AI-generated picture books, where the art is the story, for a novel, the heart is in the words.

Who is Speaking: The Villain or the Author?

The most difficult “problematic” books are those where the author’s voice begins to coerce the reader. There is a balance between a character doing something inhumane (which is characterization necessary to the plot) and an author acting as a “dictator” for how the reader must feel.

Character Perspective vs. Author Agenda

Example between a character’s view and the author’s agenda.

  • The Character: If a villain kills a puppy, that is the character acting.
  • The Author: If the prose assumes the reader agrees with a cruel sentiment, or tries to impose an ideal, that is the author dictating emotion.

Reviewing Ideological and Harmful Content Professionally

If I encounter a book that includes some sensitive and problematic chapters that feel like a trap for a specific agenda or an attack on a group, I remain professional. I don’t mirror aggression with more of the same. I point out what was well-written, but I will warn my followers of the triggers so they can make an informed decision.

As a creator I invite all voices, because I want to have access to as many types of personalities and points of view to create credible characters in my world, but if you read for pleasure and you already learn and get enough reference from real life of antagonizing and upsetting ideals, then focus on the positive aspects that the book may still provide. It’s hard to remember the author hasn’t written the book to personally attack us, but sometimes we belong to a community or a set of beliefs that are being criticized or attacked. It’s still good to inform others of red flags. They tend to grow in our society if we don’t address them.

Trigger Warnings in Children’s Literature

This is especially true for children’s books. The most “problematic” kids’ books are often the most eye-opening. They provide children with the empathy and tools to recognize a friend in distress or a secret they might be carrying. I applaud the educators who read alongside children to navigate these heavy themes together.

Final Thoughts on Ethical Book Reviews

Words can damage, but they can also activate empathy. I don’t use my reviews to attack. I use them to inform. Even in a project that feels like a first draft, there is a human connection to be found. As a reviewer, set your boundaries. As a reader, stay curious. What is negative to one person might be the exact reason another person buys the book. By staying polite and non-destructive, we keep the door open for storytelling to do what it does best: bridge the gap between different worlds. Ethical book reviews are not about silencing stories, but about guiding readers with honesty, empathy, and care.

Recommended Posts

  • Spooky Halloween Traditions From Around the World

    Jenny October 30, 2026
  • How to Write Impactful Captions for Instagram

    Jenny October 23, 2026
  • 6 Books That Deserve Their Own Screen Adaptation

    Kristin October 16, 2026
  • A graphic blog banner with a light grey textured background featuring five book covers arranged around a central white label that reads "5 books from New Zealand Read The World #17". In the bottom right corner is a rounded rectangular badge of the New Zealand flag. The visible book covers include The Whale Rider, Rangikura, The Bone People, Greta & Valdin, and Better the Blood.

    5 Powerful Books by Māori Authors You Need to Read

    Jenny June 5, 2026
  • Blog banner with the title 'The Importance of Trigger Warnings in Books' overlaid on a flat lay of Nicholas Sparks novels, including 'The Longest Ride' and 'The Last Song'.

    The Importance of Trigger Warnings in Books: A Complete Guide for Readers

    Jenny April 10, 2026

Recent Posts

Self-Service, Full-Service, or UGC: Choosing the Best Book Tour Service for Your Book
Self-Service, Full-Service, or UGC: Choosing the Best Book Tour Service for Your Book
How Using a Reading Tracker Changed My Reading Habits
How Using a Reading Tracker Changed My Reading Habits
AI use at Bookinfluencers.com. Our policy and expectations.
AI use at Bookinfluencers.com. Our policy and expectations.
7 South Pacific Books Written by Local and Indigenous Authors
7 South Pacific Books Written by Local and Indigenous Authors
Spooky Halloween Traditions From Around the World
Spooky Halloween Traditions From Around the World
How to Write Impactful Captions for Instagram
How to Write Impactful Captions for Instagram

authors

Antina (18)
Guest Blogger (19)
Helena Kulikowska (6)
Jenny (39)
Kristin (17)
Maren (19)
Monisha (1)
Paula (29)
Sanne (1)

Categories

Author and Publisher (20) Author Interview (10) Featured (20) Popular (97)
Bookinfluencers.com Blog

Thank you for visiting our blog.
We are the bridge between the reading community and you. Reach out to us if you'd like to collaborate with bookish creators.

Page Links

  • For Authors/Brands
  • For Book influencers
  • Testimonials
  • Book Tours
  • Contact Us

Instagram Feed

bookinfluencerscom

🌎 Global Book Promotions
➡️ 1000+ campaigns, 10K+ creators
📚 For (indie) authors, publishers and bookish brands

A little update on GenAI from our team 📩💜 We beli A little update on GenAI from our team 📩💜

We believe creativity is human. That’s why we’re updating our AI policy to put creators, authors and the people behind every book and account first.

Going forward, we reserve the right to decline books where the author has disclosed the use of GenAI. We’ll lead with trust and transparency, and we’re committing to keeping GenAI out of our own social content, too.

Because what makes this community special is YOU. Your creativity, your ideas and your stories. 📚💜

Here’s to celebrating the humans behind it all! ✨

👩🏼‍💻You can now find our updated GenAi policy on Bookinfluencers.com

#aipolicy #genai #aibooks #bookstagram
BILINGUAL BOOK TOUR 🌍🎄 For the first time, the hol BILINGUAL BOOK TOUR 🌍🎄 For the first time, the holiday classic, ’Twas the Night Before Christmas, comes to life in an award-winning series of bilingual books in languages from French to Spanish, Hindi to Chinese! 💫 And this year, this beautiful poem celebrates its 200th anniversary! Come celebrate it with us & @christmas200books 📗

🤍 Join the international book tour on Bookinfluencers.com - open international 

#bilingualbooks #christmasbooks #twasthenightbeforechristmas #christmas200 #twasthenightbeforechristmasbilingual
SPICY ROMANCE REC 🖤Obsession, enemies-to-lovers an SPICY ROMANCE REC 🖤Obsession, enemies-to-lovers and all the sports romance vibes? We read Hard Count by Lucas Malone (@lucastmalone)! 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️

#sportsromance #mmromance #spicyromance
✨ “When a sacred journey is corrupted by ambition, ✨ “When a sacred journey is corrupted by ambition, a quest for unity becomes a struggle for control…” ✨
We read THE WANDERING STARS by J. D. Rasch (@jodyrasch) with our community, a philosophical epic fantasy novel 🔮

👉🏼 Swipe to find out what everyone said about this book 

@ireadbookstours #thewanderingstars #epicfantasy #fantasybooks #fantasyreader
READ AROUND THE WORLD 💫 Have you read a book from READ AROUND THE WORLD 💫 Have you read a book from one of these countries? If the answer is no, this is your sign to do a Read Around The World-challenge! ❤️ We’ve got a lot of recs from you, hand-picked by us and our community.

🔗 Find out all the recs on Bookinfluencers.com/blog 

#readaroundtheworld #readdiverse #ownvoices
HOLIDAY ROMANCE 💖🎄 Here are 24 books to put on you HOLIDAY ROMANCE 💖🎄 Here are 24 books to put on your list this holiday season! Let us know: have you already read a holiday romance? 👀

#holidayromancebooks #holidayromance #christmasromance #indieauthors #newbookreleases
BOOKISH CONTENT IDEAS 💜 Do you need some inspirati BOOKISH CONTENT IDEAS 💜 Do you need some inspiration for new bookish content? We are here for you with content ideas for november! 📖 Save this post for later. 👋🏼 

#bookishcontent #bookinfluencers #bookishcontentideas #bookstagram #contentideas | bookish content ideas for november
An impactful memoir 🤍 Our community discovered Ris An impactful memoir 🤍 Our community discovered Rise After Silence by Anne Aspler (@dr.anneaspler), a memoir of an ER Doctor and the patients who healed her. A beautiful and moving memoir, like many of you said. 

🚨TRIGGER WARNINGS: sexual assault, domestic abuse, serial rape, schizophrenia and severe mental illness, homelessness, religious fundamentalism, foster care trauma, PTSD, addiction, childhood violence

💙 “It left me feeling so moved and reflective. It’s vulnerable, deeply touching, and such a powerful read about breaking the cycle of silence.” - @minaareads

💙 “It reminds me how much of what we inherit is beyond our control, but what we choose to carry forward is not” @savor.your.reads 

💙 “Ultimately this is quite a difficult read featuring some heavy topics, but Aspler handles everything with such warmth, compassion and even litters the pages with some humour along the way. I was genuinely moved in too many ways that once I finished reading, I had to re-read a second time”  @x_miss_mcrae_x 

#riseaftersilence #memoir #childhoodtrauma #memoirstoread
FIREFLY WEDDING TOUR 🦋 Satoko Kirigaya has everyth FIREFLY WEDDING TOUR 🦋 Satoko Kirigaya has everything a noblewoman could want, except time. With her life running out, she’s determined to marry well. Meet FIREFLY WEDDING by Oreco Tachibana 👰🏻‍♀️🤍 

📗 Open for US/CA/UK & Irish manga creators
💰 Incentives available - close your own deal on Bookinfluencers.com

#mangareaders #mangacommunity #fireflywedding #vizmanga #mangagirl
4 NEW BOOK TOURS 💜 We’ve got 4 international campa 4 NEW BOOK TOURS 💜 We’ve got 4 international campaigns lined up for you in collab with @thewildrosepress. Which one will you be joining this fall? 💫

📕 Beyond Valor by H.G. Hedger (@gammiehedger)
📙 Murder Richly Deserved by Roxanne Dunn (@roxannepebblesdunn)
📗 Evergreen Evermore by Margaret Izard (@mizardauthor)
📘 Dying To Meet The Newcomer by Judith Fournie Helms 

#arcreaderswanted #romanticsuspense #historicalromantasy #fantasyreaders #cosycrime
YA FANTASY TOUR 🏛️ If you loved The Midnight Libra YA FANTASY TOUR 🏛️ If you loved The Midnight Library, meet The Alternate World by Kathryn Starke (@KathrynStarke)! This YA contemporary fantasy makes you think about the choices you make in your life. 💜 

What are you going to choose to do? Welcome to The Alternate World. 💫

THE BOOK TOUR... 
🇺🇸 is open for bookish US creators
💰 comes with incentives for creators - close your own deal on the platform
🔗 is waiting for you to join on bookinfluencers.com

@CreativeMindsPublications #TheAlternateWorld #yafantasybooks #yafantasy #youngadultfantasy #fantasybooks
ROMANCE BOOK TOUR 🦋 Are you a fan of rivals-to-lov ROMANCE BOOK TOUR 🦋 Are you a fan of rivals-to-lovers, forced proximity, and a hero who falls first? Then we have the perfect campaign for you! 🥰

We’re looking for influencers to read and promote A MATCH FOR THE MARQUESS by Chelsea Bobulski (@chelseabobulski). A charming historical romance filled with witty banter, spirited competition & unexpected partnerships. 🏰

THIS BOOK TOUR...
🇺🇸 is open for US creators with a minimum of 2K followers
💰 has incentives for influencers - close your own deal on our platform
🔗 waiting for you to join on Bookinfluencers.com

#historicalromance #romancebooks #indieromance #amatchforthemarquess #nospice @havenfiction
This YA contemporary NEEDS to be on your TBR, acco This YA contemporary NEEDS to be on your TBR, according to our community. 🧡 We read the newest book by Renee Watson (@harlemportland) with our lovely community. And oh, how we loved this book! This is Everything New Again. ✨

👉🏼 Swipe to find out what our community said about this book

Have you read this one yet? 👀

#bookstagram #everythingnewagain #yabookstagram #reneewatson @bloomsburypublishing
She was raised in a cult. Now she tears them apart She was raised in a cult. Now she tears them apart. 🤯 Meet THE SILENT DOCTRINE by M.K. Mercer, a new psychological thriller coming to you on November 24th! Come join the new international book tour with us now and find out more. 🤫

THIS BOOK TOUR:
🌍 is open international
💰 comes with incentives for creators - close your own deal on the platform
🔗 is waiting for you to join on bookinfluencers.com

ABOUT THE BOOK
🌄 South of San Francisco, a mountain retreat offers something the modern world has forgotten how to provide: silence. The Solen Center offers people suffering from anxiety, distraction, and stress a unique path to relief. No phones. 
🤫 No talking. Only the body, the breath, and a focus on one’s hands. People arrive burned out and leave utterly transformed. 
🔐 But unbeknownst to them, inside the therapeutic practice is a secret that turns visitors into future unwitting operatives, committing acts for some of the world’s most dangerous people, with no memory of having done so. 
👁️ A peculiar nineteen-minute gap in three apparently unrelated crimes leads FMC Lena to the Solen Center. What she finds there suggests thousands of untraceable, unsolved crimes. But the only way to prove it is for Lena to join.

#psychologicalthrillers #thrillers #bookrecommendations #thesilencedoctrine
NOVEMBER RELEASES BY INDIE AUTHORS 💜🕯️ Here are 12 NOVEMBER RELEASES BY INDIE AUTHORS 💜🕯️ Here are 12 books to put on your list this month! 

✨ Save this post to find your next read 
🍂 Let us know your favorite new release for this month below - especially if its an indie one!

#novemberreads #indiereleases #newbookrelease #indieauthors #newbookrelease
HAPPY RELEASE DAY TO THE RUSSIAN RISK BY DAHLIA! 🩷 HAPPY RELEASE DAY TO THE RUSSIAN RISK BY DAHLIA! 🩷 If you love books by Elle Kennedy and Ana Huang, this indie release needs to be on your radar. The Russian Risk by Dahlia (@mnightdahlia) is out now. A college romance where he falls first. Swipe to find out more 👉

🩷 Opposites Attract
🩷 Dual POV
🩷 He falls first
🩷 “Bad” Boy with a Soft Side
🩷 Family Trouble (MMC)
🩷 Secret Ticking Clock (MMC)
🌶️ Spice level: 3.5 out of 5

Add The Russian Risk to your tbr!

#therussianrisk #romancebooks #spicyromance #indieromance
PICTURE BOOK REC 🐻‍❄️ We read The Adventures of Be PICTURE BOOK REC 🐻‍❄️ We read The Adventures of Belle Bear by Kathy Akopov Guillory (@belle_be4r) with our community. A heartwarming picture book about courage, self-confidence, and discovering the bravery to be yourself, no matter where life takes you. ❤️ 

📘 Will you add this one to your list? 

#theadventuresofbellebear #picturebooks #kidlit #childrensbooks #booksforkids
PICK A DRINK, GET A BOOK REC 🧡 Happy Halloween! We PICK A DRINK, GET A BOOK REC 🧡 Happy Halloween! We’ve lined up 6 drinks for you and you will get a hand-picked book rec with it. Which one did you choose? 🎃

#halloweenbooks #spookyreads #halloween #pickadrink
THRILLER REC 🖤👁️ Unreliable narrators, buried secr THRILLER REC 🖤👁️ Unreliable narrators, buried secrets, fractured memories, and twists that kept me guessing. Our community had a great time reading When Mountains Crumble(d) by Claudine Discala (claudinediscala) 🧠

Fun fact: the author herself was a private investigator for 20 years, which makes this series even more interesting if you ask us! 

📙 Will you add this series to your tbr? 

#whenmountainscrumble #psychologicalthriller #thrillerreaders #murdermysterybooks #murdermystery
HORROR READS 🖤 Here are 13 spooky books to put on HORROR READS 🖤 Here are 13 spooky books to put on your list this fall! 

❤️ SAVE this post for later 
🗣️ Did we forget a great new horror release? Let us know in the comments!

#newbookrelease #indieauthor #horrorbookstagram #horrorbooks #horrorauthor
Follow on Instagram

2023 © Bookinfluencers.Com. All Rights Reserved.